Talk:IndieLand

Notability of IndieLand

This is honestly a 50-50 tossup as far as NEVENT goes, but I think it just barely passes it when factoring in the sources from before the controversy: GameDaily, GameSpot, Bleeding Cool, Tubefilter, DualShockers and TheGamer. There's also enough significant detail about the event individually, such as its origins, games featured and guests, that would be too out of scope for the Completionist article, making it a valid split. More coverage will probably come in the future as it's a fairly ongoing situation, but there's enough here to work. However, if notability is still questioned, a merge discussion would be more appropriate. I generally refrain from using Dexerto, but compared to most of their other articles it seems more in line with decent journalism, and each article provides crucial info about the event's history before the allegations. This is probably an acceptable instance of the source.

I tried to adhere to NPOV as much as possible, posting both (keyword: BOTH) positive claims of the event before the allegations, and subsequent details about the allegations themselves. Preemptive note for all readers: I highly urge you to separate your biases before reading or editing this article. This is not an endorsement nor a disparagement of the event in the slightest. It merely repeats what the sources state in a neutral tone, both historically and recently. Thanks, PantheonRadiance (talk) 07:05, 28 March 2025 (UTC)