Venetia Stanley (1887–1948)

For the 17th century English beauty, see Venetia Stanley.

Beatrice Venetia Stanley
Venetia Stanley in 1915 Photograph by Dorothy Hickling
Born	(1887-08-22)22 August 1887
Died	3 August 1948(1948-08-03) (aged 60)
Occupation	Socialite
Known for	Relationship with H. H. Asquith
Spouse	Edwin Montagu ​ ​ (m. 1915; died 1924)​
Children	1
Parents	Edward Stanley (father) Mary Katherine Bell (mother)
Relatives	Lowthian Bell (maternal grandfather) Edward Stanley (paternal grandfather) Henrietta Dillon-Lee (paternal grandmother) Arthur Stanley (brother) William Goodenough (brother-in-law) Judith Venetia Montagu (daughter)

Beatrice Venetia Stanley Montagu (22 August 1887 – 3 August 1948) was a British aristocrat and socialite best known for the many letters that Prime Minister H. H. Asquith wrote to her between 1910 and 1915. Venetia was a namesake and collateral descendant of Venetia Stanley (1600–1633).

Family

Venetia was born on 22 August 1887, the youngest daughter of Edward Lyulph Stanley, 4th Baron Sheffield and Stanley of Alderley and his wife, Mary Katharine (1848–1929), daughter of Sir Isaac Lowthian Bell of Washington, co. Durham.

Venetia’s father succeeded his eldest brother, Henry Stanley, 3rd Baron Stanley of Alderley, in 1903, and by special remainder succeeded to the barony of Sheffield on the death in 1909 of his kinsman Henry North Holroyd, 3rd Earl of Sheffield.

Venetia had three brothers, Arthur, Edward John and Oliver Hugh and five sisters, Katharine Florence Clementine (died whilst young), Henrietta Margaret, Sylvia Laura and Blanche Florence Daphne. Her father had been the Liberal MP for Oldham from 1880 to 1885, after which he concentrated on educational reform. On his succession to the peerage in 1903 Stanley inherited estates at Alderley Park, Cheshire and Penrhos house, Anglesey.

The Coterie

Venetia was member of the coterie, a fashionable and famous set of English aristocrats and intellectuals of the 1910s, widely quoted and profiled in magazines and newspapers of the period. They met constantly, at balls and dinners in town and leisurely country house parties, and they cultivated all the pleasures of civilization. They indulged their high spirits in treasure-hunts, fancy dress balls, and deliciously illicit evenings playing poker. They held riotous parties that went on till dawn and their doings were written up by a shocked and delighted press.

The Asquith correspondence

Venetia and Asquith initially became acquainted through her childhood friendship with his daughter, Violet Asquith. Asquith admitted that he had 'a slight weakness for the companionship of clever and attractive women'. By 1907, when Venetia was 20, she was enrolled in what his wife, Margot, banteringly called his 'little harem'.

Venetia's special relationship with the Prime Minister and his family may be dated from December 1909, when Violet Asquith's admirer, Archibald "Archie" Ian Gordon, died as a result of a motoring accident, and Venetia, by now Violet's closest woman friend, proved how effective she could be in the role of comforter.

The earliest of Asquith's extant letters to her were written in September 1910 and in the second general election of that year she went with Violet to some of his election meetings. At this time Venetia was just one of several women who received Asquith's letters, he enjoyed writing letters to women in high society.

In 1912 Asquith and Edwin Montagu, a Liberal MP who was one of Asquith's protégés went to Sicily on holiday. Asquith had persuaded Venetia to leave a skiing trip in Switzerland to come with Violet to join him and Montagu in Sicily. Their arrival was slightly delayed owing to Violet having had tonsillitis.

Letter writing was one of Asquith's recreations. Asquith was an extremely assiduous correspondent. He wrote almost entirely to his women friends, these personal letters are of no great political interest. He sought from his correspondence 'not counsel', 'but comfort, communication, and relief'. He told a cabinet colleague in 1912 that 'he knew how to write to people in accordance with the prospect of letters being retained or destroyed; and he wrote accordingly'. The Letters written to Venetia from March 1914 to May 1915 are the exception to all this. Although Asquith knew that they were being kept he filled them with personal, political, and military secrets of every kind; and they include constant appeals for Venetia's counsel. They constitute the most remarkable self-revelation ever given by a British Prime Minister; and it is not likely that they will come to be matched.

After 1912 his letters to Venetia became more frequent, and he contrived to meet her when she was in London. Although, unlike an earlier Venetia Stanley (1600–1633), she had few pretensions to beauty, she was bright, intelligent, sympathetic, classically educated, well-read and fond of fun.

Venetia seems to have written to Asquith almost as often, but Asquith apparently destroyed Venetia's. More than 560 of Asquith's letters to Venetia, running to some 300,000 words have survived. Almost all were written between January 1912 and May 1915. The correspondence started with a 'faint trickle' in 1910 and 1911, became 'substantially more' in 1912, there were about 50 in 1913, mostly of substantial length and by 1914 it became 'a flood', from July 1914 Asquith wrote at least once a day.

Venetia and Asquith also saw each other quite often. On most Friday afternoons, when they were both in London, they would find time to go for a motor drive, seated behind a chauffeur in his recently-acquired Napier, they would sometimes meet at luncheon or dinner or evening parties, and occasionally Asquith would pay an early evening call on her at her parents’ house in Mansfield Street. Asquith would stay once or twice a year at one of Lord Sheffield’s residences.

In early 1914 he was writing about three times a week; and by the end of March 1914 he was discussing the problems of the premiership with her. He looked back to the Curragh incident in that month as one during which she had been his regular 'counsellor'. Asquith later reminded Venetia of the stage ". . . when we began to talk not only of persons and books but of . . . my interests, politics, etc., and I began to acquire the habit, first of taking you into confidence, and then of consulting and relying on your judgment".

There has been some debate as to whether the affair was sexually consummated or not. Brock & Brock, editors of Asquith's Letters to Venetia Stanley (1982) maintain

it is almost certain that Asquith never became Venetia's lover in the physical sense; and it is unlikely that he even wished for this. The romantic ardour which he sustained is not easy to envisage in our age of 'permissiveness' and post-Freudian introspection. By the middle of 1914 he was deeply in love. He was becoming dependent on Venetia and the signs are that this had begun to alarm her. When he stayed for Whitsun at the other Stanley estate, Penrhos, near Holyhead, his chances of resolving the Home Rule crisis were fading and she saved him, in his own later words, 'from something very like despair'; but before he left she seems to have warned him that he could not long remain the only man in her life.

Violet Asquith supported this view, commenting in 1964 "it cannot be true. Venetia was so plain". Although at the time Lady Diana Manners thought differently. She was apparently invited to replace Venetia, but did not respond.

Marriage

Mrs Beatrice Venetia Montagu upon her marriage to Edwin Montagu in 1917.

Whether or not Venetia became the premier's mistress, by the early months of 1915 his dependence on her had become almost obsessional, for example on 30 March he wrote to her four times.

After their trip to Sicily in 1912 Venetia corresponded with Edwin Montagu, they exchanged more than thirty letters, Edwin increasingly expressing his desire for her.

Sometime before 4 August 1912 Edwin mustered enough courage to propose marriage. Venetia rejected him, for on August 4, 1912, he wrote that when she turned him down he thought of severing all ties with her. But he changed his mind. Why should he lose her friendship, which meant so much to him? Also, he clung, uncharacteristically, to optimism. As long as she was unmarried there was hope.

After her refusal Edwin travelled to India for six months resolving to now view Venetia as a friend to whom one drops a line and not as a lover to whom one bares one’s soul. Their correspondence continued with her letters getting longer and his shorter. By the summer of 1913 Edwin had forgotten his resolve and began to court Venetia again and he proposed again at the end of September, he was rejected again but he assured Venetia he would not give up the struggle.

Edwin continued to pursue Venetia during 1914, both of them were close to Asquith and neither of them wanted to hurt him but by the end of April 1915 she had made up her mind to marry Edwin.

Asquith, like others, believed that Venetia's refusal to marry Edwin in 1912 represented her settled will. By 1915 the war had altered her attitude more than the premier realized, young men were being killed at the front.

Edwin was subject to a provision in his father's will intended to deprive him of a substantial inheritance if he married outside the Jewish faith but the conventions which had come near to barring a religious conversion such as this were losing their force.

On 12 May 1915 Asquith was appalled to receive Venetia's letter announcing her engagement to Edwin. This shock may well have affected his handling of the coalition crisis which erupted two days later. The end came at the worst possible time; but, after giving him some years of help and support, this romantic friendship had reached an intensity which spelt danger whenever it might end.

Venetia's conversion was, as Venetia told Edwin, a farce. She went through the motions in order to save his family fortune. She complained that the process was boring, but in the end she memorised enough of the text to pass the test and was received into the Jewish faith.

Venetia and Edwin were married on 26 July 1915.

Venetia’s family and friends differed in their attitudes toward the marriage. Her father, then seventy-seven, was furious at his daughter’s conversion and in the days following the announcement refused to talk to either Venetia or Montagu. He “boycotted” them, to use Venetia’s term for her father’s reaction. Montagu’s family was less critical as Venetia was going to convert into their faith.

War service

In January 1915 Venetia commenced three months nurse training as a paying probationer at The London Hospital, Whitechapel.

After her training Venetia signed up as a VAD nurse at Lady Norman's war hospital at Wimereux, France in May 1915. She went on to nurse with the British Red Cross Society and at home in Charing Cross and Rutland Hospitals in 1916.

Later life

On 6 February 1923, she bore a daughter, Judith, Edwin was almost certainly not the father.

Despite Venetia's affairs, her marriage lasted until Montagu's premature death on 7 November 1924.

Once a widow, she renewed her friendship with Asquith. Venetia wrote to him shortly after Montagu’s death, it was the first letter she had written him in nearly ten years. Over the next years, they continued to exchange a few letters, but none of substance.

In November 1927 Asquith paid his last visit to Venetia. At various times in 1927 he had suffered from a loss of power in one leg. When he reached home after this visit this trouble returned and he could not get out of the car without help. He never left home again and died in February 1928.

Venetia reputedly had several affairs, including an extended one with the press magnate Lord Beaverbrook which started in 1919. The letters written immediately after Montagu’s death, and throughout the rest of the 1920s, have an intimacy that suggests that they were still lovers. Beaverbrook's relationship with Venetia was more than a sexual excursion. He genuinely liked her, admired her intelligence and respected her political acumen. She admired his brilliance and political power, and she needed his financial help.

In 1927 Beaverbrook took Venetia, Diana Cooper, Valentine Castlerosse, and Arnold Bennett to Germany. Lord Castlerosse has been described as “gross in appetite and appearance, with nimble wit concealed beneath a buffoon’s exterior . . . Beaverbrook’s court jester.’’ “What is your handicap?’’ Nancy Cunard asked him on the golf course. “Drink and debauchery,” he answered. This was exactly the company Venetia loved to keep. Arnold Bennett was reported to have been shocked “by the coarseness of the conversation between Beaverbrook and Castlerosse in front of the women. Venetia and Diana were far from shocked. Their own interest in sex prompted them to go with Castlerosse on a tour of transvestite nightclubs in Berlin.

In 1928 the Liberal Party invited her to stand as a parliamentary candidate for South Norfolk, where she had inherited Montagu's country house in Attleborough, but she declined the offer. She maintained that she lacked the discipline necessary for sustained work. There was little “fun” in being a Member of Parliament. She had seen the price Edwin had paid for the honour. While she enjoyed discussing politics, she was not prepared to work on behalf of her convictions.

After being widowed, she took an interest in flying. In 1931, she embarked on a 6,000-mile adventure in a DH Gypsy Moth piloted by Rupert Belleville. The journey took them across Russia, the Middle East and Persia. Of the journey she said, "We are going for fun only, in the simplest, cheapest, and most modern way of seeing the world". The journey was eventful, after landing on a shallow lake on the way to Sofia, with no ill effects they crashed and their plane was destroyed by fire near Sabzawar in Persia.

After a delay of a few weeks they purchased another Gypsy Moth and continued their flight northwards to Moscow. In 1932 Venetia ventured out again on a flight to Saigon.

Venetia Stanley Montagu died of cancer at her Norfolk home, Breccles Hall, near Attleborough, on 3 August 1948, shortly before her 61st birthday.

The trove of Asquith's many letters to Venetia came to light after Venetia's death. Venetia's daughter Judy Montagu surprised Sir Martin Gilbert, the official biographer of Winston Churchill, by turning up with a laundry basket full of the letters.

In popular culture

Susan Howatch's 1990 novel Scandalous Risks is a fictionalised version of the relationship between Venetia Stanley ("Venetia Flaxton") and H. H. Asquith ("Neville Aysgarth"), but set in the early 1960s.

Bobbie Neate's 2012 work Conspiracy of Secrets claims, unsupported by evidence, that her stepfather Louis Stanley was the illegitimate son of Asquith and Venetia Stanley.

Robert Harris's 2024 novel Precipice is set immediately prior and during the first years World War I it includes Asquith's letters to Venetia.

References

Bibliography

• Asquith, H. H. (1982). Brock, Michael G.; Brock, Eleanor (eds.). H.H. Asquith, letters to Venetia Stanley. Oxford: Oxford University Press. OCLC 610373573.
• Brock, Michael (2023) [2004]. "Stanley [married name Montagu], (Beatrice) Venetia (1887–1948)". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/41069. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
• Chamberlain, Muriel E. (2004). "Stanley, Henry Edward John, third Baron Stanley of Alderley and second Baron Eddisbury (1827–1903)". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/36246. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
• Curthoys, M. C. (2006) [2004]. "Stanley, Edward Lyulph, fourth Baron Sheffield, fourth Baron Stanley of Alderley, and third Baron Eddisbury (1839–1925)". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/36244. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
• De Courcy, Anne (2014). Margot at War. London: Orion. ISBN 978-0-297-86983-2.
• Gilbert, Martin (1994). In Search of Churchill. London: HarperAudio. ISBN 0-00-215356-4.
• Harris, Robert (29 August 2024). Precipice. Hutchinson Heinemann. ISBN 978-1-5291-5282-1.
• Howatch, Susan (21 June 2012). Scandalous Risks. HarperCollins UK. ISBN 978-0-00-739641-2.
• Jenkins, Roy (1964). Asquith : portrait of a man and an era. New York: Chilmark Press. OCLC 1147713789.
• Kaul, Chandrika (2012) [2004]. "Montagu, Edwin Samuel (1879–1924)". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/35074. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
• Levine, Naomi B. (1991). Politics, religion, and love : the story of H.H. Asquith, Venetia Stanley, and Edwin Montagu, based on the life and letters of Edwin Samuel Montagu. New York: New York University Press. OCLC 1150946361.
• Moulson, Tom (2014). The Millionaires' Squadron: The Remarkable Story of 601 Squadron and the Flying Sword. Barnsley, UK, S70 2AS: Pen & Sword Aviation. ISBN 978-1-78346-339-8.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location (link)
• Neate, Bobbie (5 March 2012). Conspiracy of Secrets. John Blake. ISBN 978-1-84358-372-1.
• Ziegler, Philip (1982). Diana Cooper : a biography. New York: Knopf : Distributed by Random House. OCLC 1148809611.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: publisher location (link)

Further reading

• Buczacki, Stefan (2016). My darling Mr Asquith : the extraordinary life and times of Venetia Stanley. Stratford-upon-Avon: Cato & Clarke. ISBN 978-0-9934186-0-0. OCLC 951681222. When Asquith’s letters to Venetia were published in 1982, edited by Michael and Eleanor Brock, only around half of the total 300,000 words were included. Buczacki has read the other half and found that the editors omitted a lot of social gossip and an even larger quantity of 'desperately boring material. . .'{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: postscript (link)
• Cooper, Diana (1985). Autobiography. New York: Carroll & Graf. OCLC 1028198950.